Read the full history: The Farm Soap That Almost Never Hardened Into a Bar
That bar of soap started out as a barrel of ashes. Soap was one of the very few things on a nineteenth-century farm that was genuinely manufactured at home, out of two materials the place produced anyway — and it is, strictly speaking, industrial chemistry done by people who had never heard the word hydroxide.
What it was
Soap is what you get when a fat meets a strong alkali. On a farm the alkali came out of the ash pan: hardwood ashes — oak, hickory, maple — are rich in potassium carbonate, and water poured slowly through a barrel of them runs out the bottom as lye. Softwood ashes are close to useless for it, which is why the ash hopper was fed from the hardwood pile and nowhere else. The fat came from the other end of the farm year, at hog-killing: every scrap rendered down, and whatever was too coarse for the kitchen went into the grease crock by the back door with a year of bacon drippings. Neither ingredient cost a cent, and neither had any other use.
How it worked
The ash hopper was a V-shaped wooden trough or a barrel on a slanted board, with a groove underneath to carry the liquid into a crock. Straw in the bottom so the ashes would not wash through, packed full, rainwater poured over the top a bucket at a time. What ran out was brown and slippery, and got stronger as the day went on. There was no way to measure it, so there was a test instead: drop in a fresh egg or a small potato, and if it floats with a circle the size of a quarter showing above the surface, the lye is right. Too weak and the soap never comes together; too strong and it burns. Then lye and rendered fat went into an iron kettle over an outdoor fire and were stirred with a wooden paddle — never a metal one — for hours, until the kettle thickened and, as everyone put it, came.
How people used it
What came out was usually not a bar at all. Wood-ash lye is potash — potassium rather than sodium — and potassium soap does not harden. It set up as a soft brown jelly somewhere between apple butter and axle grease, stored in a barrel or crock in the washhouse and dipped out by the cupful. Hard bars needed soda lye, and cheap manufactured soda did not arrive until the second half of the century. Soft or hard, one soap did everything: clothes on Monday, floors, the milk pails, hair, children. It was strong enough to be remembered for taking the skin off knuckles, and it was the standard remedy for poison ivy and for a child’s unfortunate vocabulary alike. No perfume, no color. It smelled like exactly what it was made of.
How long it lasted
Home soapmaking is older than the country and went out within living memory. The turning point was industrial alkali: in 1861 the Belgian chemist Ernest Solvay patented an ammonia-soda process that made soda ash cheap, and by the later part of the century a farm wife could buy a can of concentrated lye at the general store for pennies and skip the hopper entirely. Procter and Gamble put Ivory on the market in 1879, advertised as 99 and 44/100 percent pure — and it floated, so it could be found again in a washtub. After that, making your own was thrift rather than necessity, and it came back every time money went away: the 1890s, the farm depression of the 1920s, the 1930s everywhere. During the Second World War households were asked to turn in waste kitchen fat, because the glycerin in it was wanted for explosives — the same grease crock by the same back door, pointed at a different war.
Watch the full story
Short version: That Bar of Soap Started Out as a Barrel of Ashes
One more detail
The egg test is the giveaway that this was a craft without instruments. There was no hydrometer in the yard and no way to titrate a barrel of ash water, so the density of the lye was read off how high an egg rode in it — a measurement anyone could make and nobody had to be taught twice. So: how would you make soap with nothing but a woodstove, a barrel of ashes and a crock of saved grease?
Read more
Susan Miller Cavitch’s The Soapmaker’s Companion is the standard modern guide to the chemistry and practice behind all of this.
Images: Library of Congress, including Farm Security Administration photographs of soapmaking, hog-killing and farm kitchens.
