Read the full history: Why the 1787 Constitutional Convention Met Entirely in Secret
The delegates who wrote the Constitution met through the summer of 1787 with the windows shut and the debate off the record. The official journal kept the votes and almost nothing else. Nearly every line anyone quotes from that room comes instead from James Madison’s private notes — which he kept revising for decades afterward, and which were not published until 1840, four years after he died. What the delegates actually said to one another survives only in one participant’s edited account.
