Read the full history: The Chemistry Inside a Sauerkraut Crock, and Why It Actually Works
Every autumn Munich opens Oktoberfest, and beside every roast and sausage in those tents sits a heap of sauerkraut. Nobody invented sour cabbage for a party. It was invented so that people would not sicken in February.
For most of history the trouble with vegetables was that they stopped in October. Cabbage, cucumbers, beets and beans all came ripe at once, and none of it would hold. The answer, in Germany and then in the German kitchens of Pennsylvania, Ohio and Wisconsin, was a heavy stoneware crock, a sack of salt, and a few weeks of patience. That pot in the cellar was the family’s vitamin C from the first frost to the first spring greens.
What it was
A pickling crock was a straight-sided stoneware jar, fired so hot that the clay vitrified — turned to glass all the way through. That mattered more than it sounds. Cheaper redware pots wore a lead glaze that leached into anything acidic, and a crock of brine is nothing but acid. Stoneware shrugged it off.
American potteries were turning them out by the late 1700s, and by the 1890s Red Wing, Minnesota and Monmouth, Illinois were shipping them west by the trainload, each one stamped with its size in gallons, from one up to sixty. The working rule was a gallon of crock for every five pounds of vegetables, so the five-gallon crock most families kept took twenty-five pounds of shredded cabbage and gave back about nine quarts of kraut. Beside it hung the kraut cutter — a long wooden board with angled blades set into it.
How it worked
The recipe was salt and time. Shred the cabbage fine, work in salt at about a pound to forty pounds of cabbage — roughly two percent — and pack it into the crock a layer at a time, pounding each layer with a wooden stomper until the juice rises over it. That juice is the brine; no water is added. Lay a plate on top, set a scrubbed stone on the plate to hold the cabbage under the liquid, and cover it with a cloth.
Then the cabbage takes over. Bacteria already living on the leaves eat the sugars in the juice and turn them into lactic acid — Leuconostoc mesenteroides starting the job, Lactobacillus plantarum finishing it. The salt keeps the wrong microbes out for the first few days, until the acidity is strong enough to do it alone. Bubbles rise, scum is skimmed each morning, and the smell reaches the top of the cellar stairs.
At 70°F the job takes three or four weeks. In a cool cellar nearer 60°F it takes five or six, and the slow batch tastes better. When the bubbling stops you have cabbage so acidic that nothing dangerous can grow in it, and it keeps until spring.
How people used it
Kraut day came after the first frost, because a frosted cabbage is sweeter and sugar feeds the ferment. A family cut the heads on a Saturday, sliced them on the board, and filled the crock in an afternoon. A second crock usually stood beside it for cucumbers, packed in brine with dill and a few grape leaves, whose tannin kept them crisp. Through the winter someone went down with a bowl every few days, took what was needed, and put the plate and stone back. The Pennsylvania Germans ate pork and sauerkraut on New Year’s Day for luck, and still do.
But the crock’s greatest hour was at sea. In 1768 Captain James Cook loaded nearly eight thousand pounds of sauerkraut — 7,860 lb of “Sour Kroutt” — aboard the Endeavour. When the crew refused to eat it, he had it served at the officers’ table until the men demanded their share. In three years at sea, by his own account, he lost no man to scurvy, and the Royal Society gave him its Copley Medal for explaining how. Sauerkraut carries around 15 mg of vitamin C per 100 g; about 10 mg a day is enough to keep scurvy away.
How long it lasted
Fermenting cabbage in salt is old beyond counting — traditions of it run back thousands of years in China, and it was a fixture of German cookbooks by the 1600s. The stoneware crock is the American chapter. It arrived with the German settlers of the 1700s, peaked between about 1880 and 1920, and hung on through the Depression, when a crock of kraut cost almost nothing to fill.
Then the jar caught up with it. Home canning and grocery cans made sour cabbage a thing you bought, the refrigerator took over the cellar’s job, and by the 1950s the big crocks had moved to the barn as feed bins. Red Wing fired its last stoneware in 1967. The pots never wore out, which is why they sit in antique shops today — and why a few people have started filling them again.
Your turn
How would you keep vegetables through a winter with no jars, no cans and no refrigerator? Tell us in the comments.
Watch the full story
The Pickling Crock: How Sauerkraut Fed the Winter Before Refrigeration — the full episode on YouTube.
Sources and further reading
- USDA Complete Guide to Home Canning, Guide 6 — salt ratios, crock sizing, fermentation times.
- Hektoen International, “Plague of the Sea”; Royal Society — Cook’s sauerkraut and the 1776 Copley Medal.
- Pederson & Albury, New York Agricultural Experiment Station — the microbiology of sauerkraut fermentation.
- Red Wing Union Stoneware and Western Stoneware company histories.
- USDA FoodData Central — vitamin C in sauerkraut.
- Images: Library of Congress (FSA/OWI, National Photo Company, American Folklife Center, Carol M. Highsmith Archive, Prints & Photographs Division).
- Sandor Ellix Katz, The Art of Fermentation — the standard modern book on fermenting vegetables in a crock: available on Amazon.
