Home » The Cheese Press: Turning a Day’s Milk Into a Wheel That Lasted All Winter

The Cheese Press: Turning a Day’s Milk Into a Wheel That Lasted All Winter

Read the full history: The History of Cheese Pressing: From Roman Molds to Jefferson's 1,235-Pound Wheel

On a dairy farm before electricity, there was no stopping the problem a milk cow created. She gave roughly the same flood of milk every single day, heaviest of all in spring when the pasture greened and the calves came, and none of that milk would keep more than a day or two as it was. Butter solved part of the problem, turning the cream into something that would last a few weeks under salt. Cheese solved the rest, because a well-made wheel, salted and cured properly, could sit in a cool room for months without spoiling at all — the single best way anyone had found to turn a perishable flood into a durable food.

The tool that made that transformation possible was the cheese press: a wooden frame holding a long threaded screw that drove a heavy follower board down onto curds packed into a cloth-lined hoop, squeezing the whey out a little further each day until what remained was firm enough to call a true cheese. Nearly every farmhouse of any real size kept one, usually standing in the milk room, the dairy house, or the cellar, and pressing day was as routine a fixture of the farm calendar as churning butter or putting up hay.

What it was

At its simplest, a cheese press is just a controlled way to apply steady weight, and the earliest American farms did it with almost nothing: a board laid over a cloth-wrapped cheese with a few heavy stones stacked on top, the same basic principle dairies had used since well before the colonies were settled. By the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries most working farms had upgraded to a proper wooden press — two or four posts holding a crossbeam, a thick oak or maple screw threaded straight through the middle of that beam, and a follower board below it that rode down onto the hoop as the screw turned.

The hoop itself — sometimes called a cheese chessel — was a cylindrical wooden or tin mold, usually ten to fourteen inches across, lined with a fresh length of cheesecloth that would be folded up and over the curds like wrapping a parcel before the follower board went on. A full outfit — press, hoop, curd knife, and the big cauldron used to heat the milk — was often the single most expensive set of equipment in the whole dairy, and on most farms it wasn’t bought ready-made at all; it came from the local cooper or blacksmith, built to last generations rather than one season.

How it worked

Cheesemaking started with the morning’s milk, sometimes combined with the evening milking held back and skimmed overnight. It was warmed gently over the fire to something close to body temperature, and then rennet was stirred in — traditionally a strip of dried calf’s stomach soaked ahead of time in whey or salted water, its enzyme curdling the milk into a custardy mass within the hour. The curd was sliced into small cubes with a long curd knife to let the whey separate, warmed again gently to firm it further, then drained through cloth and packed hot into the waiting hoop.

That hoop went straight under the press, and the real work began: the screw was turned down firmly at first to force out the bulk of the whey, then tightened a little more every few hours, and again the next morning, and the morning after that, over a day or two of steadily mounting pressure until almost no more liquid would come out at all. The drained whey was never wasted — it went to the hogs, into bread dough, or back to the calves. Once pressing finished, the wheel came out, was rubbed thoroughly with salt to draw off the last moisture and discourage spoilage, and was carried down to the cellar or the springhouse to begin curing — turned and re-rubbed every few days for weeks or, for a hard cheese meant to outlast the winter, for months.

How people used it

A pressed cheese was the single most efficient way a farm family had of banking a surplus of milk against the leaner months when the cows gave less, or none at all. One good wheel — often four to six pounds, sometimes much larger — could take ten pounds of milk or more to produce, and once properly cured it needed no ice, no cellar colder than the mid-fifties, and no attention beyond an occasional turning and a rub of salt or fat. A farm with several cows might press a dozen or more wheels across a single season, racked on shelves in the cheese room like a small private vault. Families ate it plain at nearly every meal, melted it into dishes, sliced it thick for a farmhand’s lunch pail, and traded or sold the surplus at the general store for cash income the farm otherwise had very little of.

A particularly good cheese could even become a kind of civic occasion. In 1801 the townspeople of Cheshire, Massachusetts pooled the milk from every cow in the parish on a single day and built a purpose-made giant press just for the occasion, producing one twelve-hundred-and-thirty-five-pound wheel that took months to cure. They hauled it to Washington by wagon and sleigh and presented it to President Thomas Jefferson as the “Mammoth Cheese” — proof that the same humble screw press scaled, in the right hands and with enough cooperative neighbors, into genuine political theater.

How long it lasted

Home cheese pressing is centuries older than the United States itself, and it held on in American farmhouses for most of the nineteenth century before industrial production finally took the job over. The turning point is usually dated to 1851, when a dairyman named Jesse Williams opened what’s generally credited as the first true cooperative cheese factory, in Rome, New York, combining milk from his neighbors’ farms into batches far larger and more consistent than any single household press could manage. The factory model spread fast through New York and then into Wisconsin over the following decades, and by the 1870s most of the cheddar sold in American stores came out of a factory vat, not a farmhouse hoop.

That didn’t end home pressing overnight, though. It persisted on smaller and more remote farms well into the twentieth century, and it came back whenever cash ran short: the farm depression of the 1890s, the hard years of the 1920s, and the Great Depression of the 1930s all saw families return to the cellar press because buying cheese instead of making it was money nobody had to spare. Rural electrification in the 1930s and 40s, and the mechanical refrigeration that came with it, finally removed the last practical reason to keep a press and a curing cellar running at all.

Your turn

How long would you be willing to wait for a wheel of cheese to finish curing before you’d call it ready to eat? Tell us in the comments.

Watch the full story

Sources and further reading

  • Records of the 1801 Cheshire, Massachusetts “Mammoth Cheese” presented to President Thomas Jefferson.
  • Jesse Williams’s cooperative cheese factory, Rome, New York, 1851, and its spread through New York and Wisconsin.
  • Rural Electrification Administration, established 1935 — farm electrification and home refrigeration.
  • Gianaclis Caldwell, Mastering Basic Cheesemaking: The Fun and Fundamentals of Making Cheese at Home — available on Amazon.
  • Images: Library of Congress (Prints & Photographs Division, FSA/OWI).

The Relatable History newsletter

Get new stories by email

New sourced articles on everyday objects, old ways and unsolved mysteries, delivered to your inbox. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.